I think its crazy that he's called Buttercup and yet Gary Ross allowd him/her to be BLACK! Yellow and Black are nothing like each other! They should have cast this cat as Buttercup, its perfect! Apart from the fact it has both ears in tact, but it can't be helped
I agree. You would think that casting the cat would have been the easiest part of the casting process. After all, the description of Buttercup was so specific in the book. The Harry Potter movies did a better job of casting Hermione's pet. In fact, they could have used that same cat and I would have been happy. We'll see. Maybe enough people complained that they'll fix it in the next movies.